Why Do YouTubers Change Thumbnails After Posting?

Photo of Dale
Dale is a former electrician that has since gone on to generate over $1 million in all-time affiliate commissions & become officially recognized as a Super Affiliate by the world's largest affiliate marketing training platform. Alongside running his own affiliate marketing empire, he now also teaches affiliate marketing to others through the Commission Academy platform.

If you’ve ever noticed a YouTube thumbnail change days or even weeks after a video was posted, you might wonder why that happens. It’s not just an odd quirk or a fluke in the system—there are actually some pretty strategic reasons behind it.

In this blog post, I’ll dive into the key reasons why YouTubers update their thumbnails after posting, and explore how these changes can impact video performance.

So, if you’ve been curious about this tactic, stay tuned—you’re about to get the inside scoop!

Free Training

Become a Super Affiliate Marketer 🚀

Affiliate Marketing Lesson Screenshot

Sign up for our free affiliate marketing training & learn how you can become a super affiliate in any niche. Discover powerful traffic generation methods & little-known tactics to generate the most revenue for every single click.

Does Changing YouTube Thumbnails Affect Views?

Absolutely, changing YouTube thumbnails can have a significant impact on views.

A compelling thumbnail can make the difference between a video being ignored or gaining traction. When a YouTuber notices that a video isn’t getting the expected clicks, swapping out the thumbnail can be a quick fix. It’s like giving the video a fresh coat of paint.

Often, small tweaks like adding brighter colours, clearer text, or a more eye-catching image can attract more viewers. Beyond aesthetics, thumbnails should accurately represent the video content. Misleading thumbnails might get clicks initially but can harm long-term engagement and subscriber trust.

(you can check out our guide on creating an awesome YouTube thumbnail here)

In some cases, YouTubers experiment with A/B testing, where they alternate between different thumbnails to see which one performs better. This data-driven approach ensures they choose the most effective image to increase views.

Remember, the goal is to make the video irresistible to click on while setting accurate expectations for the viewer. When done right, changing thumbnails can turn a struggling video into a viral success.

Why Do YouTubers Change Thumbnails?

YouTubers change thumbnails for several key reasons.

Firstly, engagement is crucial. If a video isn’t getting the expected clicks, a more appealing thumbnail can help. It’s all about capturing viewer interest at a glance.

Secondly, trends and relevancy play a role. A thumbnail that aligns with current trends or mimics popular formats can attract more views. It’s a way to stay fresh and competitive in a dynamic platform.

Analytics also guide decisions. YouTubers monitor performance metrics closely. If data shows a thumbnail isn’t effective, a change is in order. Adjusting the thumbnail based on viewer behaviour can enhance click-through rates.

And on top of those reasons, something as simple as feedback from the audience can prompt a change.

Viewers might suggest improvements or a creator might notice patterns in comments that indicate a need for a better thumbnail.

Overall, changing thumbnails is a strategic move to optimize visibility, engagement, and overall channel growth. It’s a small tweak that can yield significant results.

How Many Times Can You Change The Thumbnail on YouTube?

YouTube doesn’t limit the number of times you can change a thumbnail. This flexibility allows creators to experiment and find what works best for their audience.

Each time a thumbnail is updated, YouTube processes it just like it would for a newly uploaded video. So, uploaders can feel free to make adjustments as often as needed. However, constantly changing thumbnails might confuse regular viewers or disrupt branding consistency.

It’s wise to use this feature strategically. Try monitoring the performance of each change to see which thumbnail gets the best results. This data-driven approach minimizes guesswork and helps you settle on an image that truly resonates with viewers.

How To Change YouTube Thumbnail After Posting

Changing a YouTube thumbnail after posting is straightforward and can be done in just a few steps.

  1. Log In to YouTube Studio: Head over to YouTube Studio by clicking on your profile picture in the top right corner and selecting “YouTube Studio” from the dropdown menu.
  2. Navigate to Content: On the left-hand side, you’ll find a menu. Click on “Content” to see a list of all your uploaded videos.
  3. Select the Video: Find the video for which you want to change the thumbnail. Click on the video title or the pencil icon to open the video details.
  4. Change Thumbnail: In the video details page, you’ll see the current thumbnail preview. Click on “Thumbnail” to either select a new one from YouTube’s auto-generated options or upload a custom thumbnail by clicking on the “Upload thumbnail” button.
  5. Save Changes: After selecting or uploading your new thumbnail, don’t forget to click on the “Save” button in the top right corner. This will apply your changes and update the thumbnail.

And that’s it! Your video now sports a fresh new look, which can help attract more viewers. Regularly updating thumbnails based on performance can be a game-changer for your channel’s growth.

What Makes a Good YouTube Thumbnail?

A good YouTube thumbnail is eye-catching and informative. It should grab attention instantly while giving viewers an idea of what the video is about.

Clarity is Key: Use high-resolution images. Blurry or pixelated thumbnails can turn viewers away. Ensure any text is large and readable, even on smaller screens like mobile devices.

Be Visually Appealing: Bright colours and high contrast can help your thumbnail stand out. Incorporating elements like emojis or bold text can add an extra layer of appeal.

Stay On-Brand: Consistency with your branding can make your videos look professional and cohesive. Use similar colours, fonts, and styles to build a recognizable brand identity.

Express Emotion: Thumbnails that depict strong emotions can create a connection. Whether it’s surprise, joy, or curiosity, showing expressive faces can draw viewers in.

Be Honest: Your thumbnail should accurately represent the video content. Misleading thumbnails can result in quick clicks but also quick exits, which isn’t good for viewer retention.

Keep it Simple: Don’t overcrowd your thumbnail. A clear, focused image with minimal text usually performs better than a cluttered one.

Effective thumbnails are a blend of art and strategy, helping your video stand out in a sea of content and compelling viewers to click.

Testing & Comparing Thumbnails To Find The Best One

Testing and comparing thumbnails is a crucial step for optimizing video performance.

YouTube’s Official Tool: YouTube provides an official tool for testing thumbnails directly within YouTube Studio. You can compare the performance of up to three thumbnails to see which one performs best in terms of attracting clicks and viewer engagement.

Eligibility Requirements: Make sure you meet the eligibility requirements. This feature is available only on computers through YouTube Studio and requires enabling advanced features. You can test thumbnails on public long-form videos, podcast episodes, and Premiere videos once they convert to long-form, but not on videos made for kids, mature audiences, or private videos.

How to Test Thumbnails:

  1. Sign in to YouTube Studio.
  2. Select the video you want to test:
    • New Video: Click “CREATE” in the upper right-hand corner, then “Upload videos” and upload your video.
    • Existing Video: From the left menu, go to “Content” and click on the video you want to edit.
  3. Under ‘Thumbnail’, click “Test and compare.”
  4. Upload up to three thumbnails to test.
  5. Click “DONE.” The test will start once the video is published.

Monitoring the Test: You can stop the test at any point by selecting ‘Stop and set’ to manually choose one of the thumbnails.

Test Results: Results can take a few days to two weeks to finalize, depending on factors like thumbnail diversity and the number of impressions. Once ready, results are available in YouTube Studio. You can then choose the winning thumbnail or rerun the test for further optimization.

This testing process enables creators to make data-driven decisions and continually refine their thumbnails for maximum impact.

So, there you have it—changing thumbnails is just one of the many strategies YouTubers use to boost their video performance and keep their audience engaged.

And with that in mind, if you’re looking to dive deeper into strategies that can help you succeed on YouTube and beyond, why not check out our free affiliate marketing course?

It’s packed with valuable insights to help you grow your online presence and turn your passion into profit.

You can sign up here completely free of charge.

But either way, whatever you decide to do, I sincerely hope this post helped you out & if you happen to have any additional questions or comments, don’t hesitate to leave them below.

Free Training:

Launch a Thriving Online Business 💸

Training Video Preview

Our free step-by-step training will teach you how you can turn any passion or interest into a thriving online business even if you're a beginner with absolutely no previous experience. Sign-up today & learn a skill that could change your life.

Leave a comment